Are the Church Leaders infallible?

The Man Who Built His Faith on the Church Leaders Instead of the Bible

Whenever he asked about a doctrine in his church, the same answer came back: «Thus taught the church leaders, and this is the consensus of the church, and the mind of the church does not err.» So he learned to build his faith on what Saint John Chrysostom said, and Saint Basil, and Saint Gregory, not on the Bible alone. He was told that the Bible cannot be understood except by the consensus of the church leaders, and that whoever interprets it apart from them goes astray. He accepted this for years. But one day he began to read the church leaders themselves, and found two things that astonished him: that they disagreed among themselves on many matters, and that they themselves subordinated their own words to the Bible and called people to it. Then one evening he read the words of the apostle Paul about the Bereans, who tested the teaching of an apostle by the Scriptures: "searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so" (Acts 17:11). If the word of an apostle is tested by the Scriptures, how much more the words of the church leaders?

And the answer of the Holy Bible to the question of the authority of the church leaders is a single sentence which, once grasped, frees every soul taught to set the words of the church leaders equal to the Word of God: no. The writings of the church leaders are not an authority equal to the Holy Bible, nor an infallible rule of faith. The written Word of God alone is the supreme rule by which every teaching is judged, even the teaching of the church leaders themselves. And we honour the church leaders as useful witnesses to history and interpretation, but we do not make them an authority that adds to the Bible or interprets it in a binding, infallible way. As for the teaching that the consensus of the church leaders is infallible and cannot err, it contradicts the testimony of the church leaders themselves, the reality of their disagreement, and the declared sufficiency of the Bible.

What Orthodox Theology Teaches About the Church Leaders

Let the position be stated fairly. Orthodox theology teaches that Sacred Tradition — including the writings of the church leaders, the decisions of the councils, and the liturgical life of the church — carries authority alongside the Bible, and that the Bible itself is the fruit of the church and its tradition, so that it is not rightly understood except within the «mind of the church» expressed in the consensus of the church leaders. And within this framework, whoever interprets the Bible apart from the church leaders is seen as exposing himself to error, because he rejects the guide by which God has preserved the understanding of His Word.

And the fruit of this teaching is that the believer cannot come to the Bible directly and trust that the Holy Ghost guides him in it, but remains suspended upon a later human consensus. And we do not deny that there is richness, wisdom, and a precious witness to the faith of the early church in the writings of the church leaders — indeed we read them with profit and honour — but profit is one thing and infallible authority is another. The error is not in reading the church leaders, but in raising them to the rank of the Word of God, and making their consensus infallible and incapable of error.

The Church Leaders Themselves Subordinated Their Words to the Bible

The most telling reply to raising the church leaders above the Bible is that the church leaders themselves refused it. For the best of the church leaders declared that their authority was below the authority of the Bible, and called people to test their words by it. This is the very pattern of the Bible itself: the apostle Paul, inspired as he was, praised the Bereans for testing his teaching by the Scriptures: "These were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so" (Acts 17:11). If the teaching of an inspired apostle is tested by the Scriptures and its testers are praised, how much more should the words of uninspired church leaders be tested.

And the apostle Paul warned against raising any authority above the gospel delivered, even an apostle or an angel: "But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed" (Galatians 1:8). So if an apostle or an angel is subject to this touchstone, the church leaders are more so. And the touchstone in all this is the delivered word, not the consensus of later teachers.

The Church Leaders Disagreed Among Themselves

And there is a historical reality that demolishes the idea of an infallible consensus: that the church leaders disagreed among themselves on many matters. They disagreed about the canonicity of some books of the Bible, about the interpretation of many texts, and about various theological and pastoral questions. So what infallible consensus is to be relied upon if the church leaders themselves did not reach consensus? And who decides which of the church leaders was right when they disagreed? There is no reference for that but the Bible, so the Bible returns as the judge, not the church leaders.

And the claim that «the consensus of the church leaders» is infallible collides with the fact that this consensus exists only where they agreed, and where they agreed, they agreed because they followed the plain Bible. So their authority is in truth borrowed from the Bible: when they agreed with it they were right, and when they contradicted it they erred. And this very thing is what makes the Bible — not the church leaders — the rule. And the Lord Jesus Christ warned us of the danger of putting the tradition of men in the place of the commandment of God: "Thus have ye made the commandment of God of none effect by your tradition" (Matthew 15:6). For when a human teaching is raised to the rank of the commandment, it nullifies it, however good the intention.

The Bible Alone Is Inspired and Sufficient

Why is the Bible alone the rule, and not the church leaders? Because the Bible alone is inspired by God, while the church leaders are diligent teachers who err and are right by turns. The apostle Paul declared the infallibility and sufficiency of the Bible: "All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness: That the man of God may be perfect, throughly furnished unto all good works" (2 Timothy 3:16-17). «Perfect, throughly furnished unto all good works» — so the Bible alone makes the believer perfect, and there remains no deficiency for the writings of the church leaders to complete.

And the Bible alone is called inspired in this sense; none of the trustworthy church leaders claimed for himself this infallible inspiration. Indeed Peter spoke of the writings of the apostle Paul as «scriptures» along with the rest of the holy Scriptures (2 Peter 3:16), and never said that of the writings of a later teacher. So the Bible is a category standing by itself, above every human writing, however great its author and however holy his life. And the Word of God is living and powerful, used by the Holy Ghost to guide the believer: "For the word of God is quick, and powerful" (Hebrews 4:12).

The Holy Ghost Guides the Believer in the Word

It may be said: but is not the ordinary believer unable to understand the Bible alone, so that he needs the church leaders as guides? And the Bible answers that the Holy Ghost, who dwells in every believer, is the teacher who guides him in the Word. The Lord Jesus Christ promised: "But the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost... he shall teach you all things" (John 14:26). And the apostle John wrote: "But the anointing which ye have received of him abideth in you, and ye need not that any man teach you" (1 John 2:27). So the believer is not left to himself, nor suspended upon a human consensus, but has the Holy Ghost as teacher.

And this does not mean the believer dispenses with living teachers of the Word or with reading those who went before; for God gave the church teachers and pastors (Ephesians 4:11), and there is profit in reading the church leaders. But the human teacher, whether living or among the ancients, remains a servant of the Word and not a master over it, tested by it and not testing it. So the difference is that the Holy Ghost and the Word are the rule, and the teachers — including the church leaders — are a help under the rule, not a rule over the believer.

The Fathers at Their Best — Pointing to Scripture

The greatest Fathers of the church were great precisely because they pointed to Scripture. Chrysostom's greatness lay in his verse-by-verse exposition of the New Testament. Augustine's greatness lay in his wrestling with the text of Romans and the Psalms. Athanasius held firm against Arianism because of what Scripture said about Christ, not because of tradition. When the Fathers were most faithful, they were most biblical. And their own best advice was to read and test everything by Scripture. To elevate their tradition above Scripture is to contradict their own finest impulse.

The Berean Principle Applied to Orthodox Tradition

"These were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so." (Acts 17:11). Apply this Berean principle to Orthodox tradition: search the Scriptures daily to see whether these things are so. Purgatory — is it in Scripture? No. Theosis as a process of acquiring salvation — is it in Scripture? Not in that form. The seven sacraments as automatic grace-conveyers — is it in Scripture? No. The Berean principle cuts through centuries of accumulated tradition and asks the one decisive question: what does Scripture say?

A Word to the Sincere Orthodox Believer

If you love God and honour the Fathers — honour them best by doing what they commended: read Scripture daily, test every teaching by it, and hold fast to what the Word of God clearly teaches. The Independent Baptist church does not dismiss the Fathers; it places them in their proper position — teachers under Scripture, not authorities above it. Come to Scripture with a humble, open heart. Let the living Word speak. "Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and thou shalt be saved." (Acts 16:31).

The Reformation Recovery

When the Reformers returned to Scripture, they found that centuries of accumulated tradition had moved the church far from its apostolic foundation in many areas. Luther's great discovery was that justification is by faith alone — found in Romans 1:17, always there in Scripture but buried under layers of tradition. The recovery of Scripture's authority was not the destruction of the church's heritage; it was the purification of that heritage. And the principle they recovered — Scripture judging tradition — is the biblical principle the Bereans practised and the apostles taught. It is the only safeguard against the endless accumulation of human additions to the gospel.

An Invitation to Read

The simplest response to everything in this article is this: read the Bible for yourself. Not through the lens of tradition, not filtered by councils, but directly — starting with the Gospel of John. "These are written, that ye might believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God; and that believing ye might have life through his name." (John 20:31). Scripture was written for you personally, to produce personal faith and personal life in Christ. Read it. Let it speak. "Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and thou shalt be saved." (Acts 16:31).

What the Fathers Said About Scripture's Authority

The greatest Fathers affirmed Scripture's supremacy over their own writings. Augustine wrote: "Do not follow my writings as you would Holy Scriptures. Instead, where you find me in error, do not believe." Chrysostom: "Let us not therefore carry about the notions of the many, but examine into the facts." Athanasius, defending the Nicene faith against the Arian majority, appealed not to tradition but to Scripture: "Vainly do they run about with the pretext that they have demanded Councils for the faith's sake; for the divine Scripture is sufficient above all things." The Fathers at their best pointed to Scripture's authority — above their own. To elevate their tradition above Scripture is to contradict their own finest theological instinct.

Three Practical Questions About the Fathers

When a Father's teaching differs from what Scripture plainly says — which governs? When two Fathers disagree on a theological question — what is the arbiter? When a council's decision contradicts Scripture — what is the believer's obligation? The biblical answer to all three is the same: Scripture governs, Scripture arbitrates, and the believer's obligation is to Scripture's plain teaching. This does not make the Fathers useless — they remain enormously valuable commentators and interpreters. But it places them in their correct relationship to Scripture: tools in Scripture's service, not authorities alongside it.

The Simplest Summary

The Fathers are valuable teachers; Scripture is the infallible authority. Where they agree, follow the Scripture. Where they disagree with Scripture, follow the Scripture. Where tradition has added to Scripture without scriptural basis, test it against Scripture and hold only what Scripture confirms. This approach honours the Fathers without idolising them, and honours Scripture without dismissing history. It is the approach of the Bereans, the Reformers, and the Independent Baptist church — and it produces the most doctrinally sound and spiritually mature faith. "Search the scriptures; for in them ye think ye have eternal life." (John 5:39).

The Berean Standard — The Final Word

The greatest tribute to the Fathers is to do what the best of them commended: test everything by Scripture. "These were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so." (Acts 17:11). Be a Berean. Search the Scriptures daily. Test every teaching — including Orthodox tradition — by the Word of God. Hold fast to what Scripture confirms. And build your faith on the Rock that cannot move: the living, breathing, God-breathed Word that speaks with authority no council and no Father can match. "Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and thou shalt be saved." (Acts 16:31).

The Fathers point to Scripture. Scripture points to Christ. Christ is the way. Follow that chain — and you will never go wrong.

Read the Fathers. Honour their faithfulness. Learn from their insights. But place the Bible above them always — as they themselves, at their best, would have you do.

Closing — Build on the Word, and Read the Church Leaders Under It

If you have built your faith on the consensus of the church leaders instead of the Bible, the Lord is calling you to build on His Word alone, and to read the church leaders under it, not over it. You do not need an infallible human consensus to interpret the Bible for you, for the Holy Ghost who dwells in you guides you, and the Word itself is sufficient to make you perfect. And the church leaders, at their best, themselves point you to the Bible and not to themselves. And at the heart of this Bible is one message that saves: that the Lord Jesus Christ died for your sins, was buried, and rose again the third day (1 Corinthians 15:3-4).

Believe this Word. Receive the Christ it proclaims. And of everything you are told, even if it is ascribed to the greatest of the church leaders, ask: is this in agreement with the Bible? If it agrees, receive it; and if it contradicts, the Bible is the judge. And build your whole life on the Word that does not pass away: "but my words shall not pass away" (Matthew 24:35).

A Special Prayer

If you have come to see that the Word of God alone is the infallible rule, and that the church leaders are read under it and not over it, you may come to God now, relying on His Word. You do not need a mediator nor a human consensus; the Word proclaims to you the Saviour plainly, and the Holy Ghost guides you in it. What saves you is not the words of a prayer, but the faith that the Lord Jesus Christ died for you and rose again. So pray from your heart to the living God who hears:

"O great and holy and loving God, the one true God: I have long built on the words of men, and I see now that Thy Word alone is the infallible, sufficient truth. I confess that I am a sinner, and that no consensus nor tradition can save me. I believe Thy Word, which proclaims that the Lord Jesus Christ died on the cross for my sins, was buried, and rose again the third day. I trust in Him alone as my Saviour, and I build on Thy Word alone. Forgive me, receive me, and grant me eternal life. I pray in the name of my Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ. Amen."

After You Have Prayed

If you prayed this prayer from a sincere and believing heart, then you have built on the abiding Word of God that does not pass away, you have become a child of God forever, and you have the Holy Ghost as a teacher who guides you in His Word. Here are steps to steady you:

First — read the Word of God every day. Know that the King James Version (KJV) is the truest and purest copy of the Word of God in all the world, His true and pure Word, and you will find it on this website (alinjil.com); and in Arabic, read the trustworthy Van Dyck translation. Begin with the Gospel of John, not in haste, but with meditation and prayer, for God speaks to you through His Word.

Second — test every teaching by the Bible as the Bereans did, even if it is ascribed to the greatest of the church leaders, and always ask: is this in agreement with the Bible?

Third — pray to God directly every day in words from your heart, asking the Holy Ghost to guide you in His Word.

Fourth — seek a church that honours the Word of God and makes it the supreme rule, join the fellowship of believers, and be baptized in obedience to the Lord.

Fifth — bear witness to others that the Word of God alone is the infallible rule, especially to those who have built their faith on the consensus of the church leaders.

And keep reading the Word of God in the King James Version, the truest and purest Word of God in the world, and in the Van Dyck in Arabic — both found on this website — that you may grow in the knowledge of the One who saved you by His Word.

A Personal Word to You, Dear Reader

Thank you for taking the time to read this message about the sufficiency of the Word of God, the place of the church leaders under it, and the salvation it proclaims through the Lord Jesus Christ. If you have received Christ as your own personal Saviour, you have built on the rock that does not pass away, and you have become a child of God forever. "Heaven and earth shall pass away, but my words shall not pass away" (Matthew 24:35).

We encourage you to begin reading the Gospel of John for yourself, to continue in the Word of God in the King James Version — the truest and purest Word of God in the world — and in the Van Dyck in Arabic, both found on this website (alinjil.com), and to share this good news with everyone who has built his faith on the words of men. May God richly bless you as you build your life on His Word alone.

← Back to FAQs